Direct Tax
Consulting
ESG Advisory
Indirect Tax
Growth Advisory
Internal Audit
BFSI Audit
Industry Audit
Valuation
RBI Services
SEBI Services
IRDA Registration
AML Advisory
IBC Services
NBFC Compliance
IRDA Compliance
Finance & Accounts
Payroll Compliance Services
HR Outsourcing
LPO
Fractional CFO
General Legal
Corporate Law
Debt Recovery
Select Your Location
GST was introduced by the Indian government to reduce tax evasion and build up a strong tax collection structure. One of the major characteristics of GST is that it supports the domestic traders to face the competition in domestic as well as the international market. Here we will analyze how smoothly the GST transition India can take place, and the lessons learned from countries that have already implemented GST.
Table of Contents
GST was first introduced in France. Some other countries which adopted the GST regime are Singapore, Malaysia, and the UK. In this article we have described about GST Transition India – A Global Analysis, GST Registration.
In the given scenario, India can learn a lot from these countries as to how Goods and Service Tax can be smoothly launched and other post-implementation points to be taken care of.
The first and foremost point of importance is the implementation of the new tax regime. It is the duty of the government to ensure smooth implementation and migration procedures. Such procedures are required to be made keeping in mind the objective of a smooth GST transition India. Enough information must be supplied to the taxpayers about the implementation and their role in the process.
If there is a lack of communication on the part of the government, then the implementation can face a backlash from the people, leading to unnecessary chaos and confusion. This happened in the case of Malaysia, where the government provided a long transition period of 1.5 years and still faced a backlash from the people.
India has adopted the Canadian model of Dual GST, where tax is charged at federal as well as state levels. In many countries, this segregation is not defined and only one tax applies. This dual tax system might result in further complications as different states are free to draw their interpretations and define their rules regarding such state taxes.
In order to expand the tax base, it has been advised to lower the tax rate[1]. Low tax rates encourage the taxpayer to come forward and register. On the other hand, if the tax rates are on the higher end, taxpayers feel discouraged and this will result in tax evasion.
This is the reason many countries like Singapore introduced lower tax rates in the initial stages of implementation of GST and gradually increased them to build up the tax base.
However, the Indian government has set the tax rates at 5%, 12%, 18% and 28%, and only staple foods are excluded from the criteria. The government is taking a bold step by not opting for a safe option.
Under the GST, all the taxpayers including small, medium and large enterprises were equated as the same and were taxed at the same rate. Even the exemption threshold was kept at 20 lakh, which results in bringing them all at par. This exemption limit was doubled to 40 lakhs for MSMEs and for north-eastern states its 20 lakh. It is a good thing as it expands the tax base, but it poses many difficulties for SMEs to comply with all the provisions with their limited resources. This is the reason countries have set the threshold limit at higher levels, for example, in Singapore this limit is at 4.8 crores and in Malaysia, it is at 75 lakhs to give some relief to SMEs.
These SMEs are granted some relief in the form of the Composition Scheme, but it comes with its share of shortcomings, as any taxpayer registered under the same cannot avail input credit, nor can they collect taxes from their customers.
In order to ensure proper working of any tax system, the most crucial part is that it has clearly defined procedures and a fast credit payment system. An effective payment system and a related infrastructure are required for this purpose. In the absence of which, proper cash flow will be adversely affected.
In the current GST regime, if there is any delay on the part of the supplier in the filing GST return, then the recipient cannot receive input credit on time. It will, as a result, increase the cost of business for such recipients.
Indian tax regulators should take a lesson from other world economies who have suffered the same issues and introduced a more effective mechanism.
The government should take effective steps to ensure that the implementation of GST does not result in inflation. The main objective of the introduction of GST is to eliminate the tax on tax effect, thus reducing the costs of goods and services. But many people may take unlawful routes to exploit the final consumers who are not well aware of these provisions.
It is the responsibility of the government to make precautionary anti-profiteering policies to protect such consumers of goods and services. This is very important as many countries faced the same problem as did Singapore when it introduced GST in 1994; a hike in the inflation rate was noticed.
The proper execution of GST is highly required. GST laws may be new to many therefore it requires proper understanding. In case of any doubts on GST related laws, feel free to contact Enterslice.
Read our article: GST on Legal Services in India: A Complete Outlook
A joint venture is a strategic business arrangement in which two or more companies collaborate...
With the rising inflation rates and various other economic factors, wealthy Americans are incre...
Before approaching the new suppliers or any other third parties, you should always go for the v...
With the increasing landscape of Fintech Companies, it is increasingly vital that fintech compl...
This blog gives a detailed description through an audit report for industrial waste by examinin...
Are you human?: 9 + 1 =
Easy Payment Options Available No Spam. No Sharing. 100% Confidentiality
The tax structure of India is divided into two types of taxes, which are direct and indirect taxes. GST is a type o...
30 Mar, 2024
CBIC has issued instructions on 28th November 2022 vide Instruction No/ 04/2022 in respect of the...
13 Dec, 2022
Chat on Whatsapp
Hey I'm Suman. Let's Talk!