ITC restrictions for availing credit in accordance with Rule 36(4) of the CGST Rules

Ruchi Gandhi

24 Jan, 2020

To overcome the malpractices of fake generation of invoices and fraudulent availment of the input tax credit by the taxpayers, an amendment was made in the CGST Rules. On 9^th October 2019, the CBIC had inserted a sub-rule (4) to Rule 36 of the CGST Rules, 2017 to impose ITC restrictions on the claim of provisional credit. In the 38^th GST Council Meeting Decisions held on 18^th December 2019, the GST Council took further decisions with regard to limits on availment of provisional ITC in GSTR-3B. Such amount of provisional ITC has been further restricted to 10%* with effect from 01-01-2020 (*earlier 20%) in respect of invoices or debit notes which fail to reflect in GSTR-2A of the recipient.

Under the present GST return filing system, full ITC claim shall not be allowed to the taxpayers if their corresponding suppliers have not uploaded the details of outward supplies to be reflected as inputs in GSTR-2A. For those non-reconciled invoices, a registered person who files GSTR-3B is allowed to avail provisional ITC only to the extent of 10% of the eligible ITC allowable in GSTR-2A. The eligible ITC is such which is available on business invoices or debit notes, successfully uploaded by the suppliers in their GSTR-1, which gets reflected in the taxpayer’s GSTR-2A.

Example on ITC restrictions

The ITC restrictions by virtue of Rule 36(4) may be apprehended well with an example. Assuming that a taxpayer furnishes his GSTR-3B for the month of January 2020, his ITC restrictions before and after the imposition of Rule 36(4) shall be as follows:

Claiming of Balance ITC

The balance ITC of Rs. 1,01,000 may be claimed proportionately in the succeeding months as and when invoices are uploaded by suppliers. For example, the eligible ITC pertaining to invoices uploaded by suppliers in the month of February 2020 amounts to Rs. 97,000. In this case, the total ITC allowed to be claimed in GSTR-3B in the month of February 2020 shall be:

Some important points

• The ITC restrictions specified under Rule 36(4) are calculated on a consolidated basis rather than supplier-wise. This means that the ITC is linked to the total credit available against all invoices uploaded by all suppliers in Form GSTR-1 and which are reflected in Form GSTR-2A.
• This restriction is applicable only to those invoices or debit notes which are required to be uploaded by suppliers in Form GSTR-1 and have not been uploaded. Apparently, full ITC can be claimed by taxpayers in respect of invoices not supposed to be reported in Form GSTR-1 such as IGST paid on imports, documents issued under RCM, credit received from ISD, etc.
• The CBIC^[1] clarified that ITC restrictions under Rule 36(4) are not imposed through GST common portal, and the taxpayers themselves are accountable to ensure that ITC is claimed in accordance with the said provisions. Therefore, such ITC must be availed on a self-assessment basis.
• This rule fails to account for circumstances where suppliers file their GST returns on a quarterly basis while the recipients file monthly returns. Thus, recipients may try to get their inward supplies from large taxpayers who opt for monthly filing of GST returns, which might pose problems for the small dealers.
• The taxpayer needs to ascertain the ITC from the auto-populated Form GSTR-2A as available on the due date of filing of returns, i.e., the cut-off date for claiming provisional credit will be the due date of filing returns only. It will be assessed based on invoices uploaded by suppliers as on the due date of filing their GSTR-1.

Impact of ITC restrictions on taxpayers

Prior to the imposition of ITC restrictions, the taxpayers used to claim full ITC while filing their GSTR-3B (as provisional credit), even though GSTR-2A reflected a lesser amount of ITC than the books of account. Now, to compulsorily reconcile the ITC claim with GSTR-2A’s eligible credit, the provisional credit is restricted to the extent of only 10% of the eligible credit value for a particular tax period. Therefore, this new rule may affect the working capital position of the taxpayer since he shall be required to pay the balance GST liability (net of credit availed) in cash, despite holding invoices for eligible input purchases made by him from suppliers during the tax period. Also, the reconciliation exercise will be a cumbersome and time-consuming activity.

Conclusion

With the implementation of ITC restrictions under Rule 36(4), a lot of confusion rippled in the minds of taxpayers concerning its practical implications. It is hopeful that the new GST return filing system, after becoming operational, shall address the issues of ITC availment in a systematic manner.