GST Circulars

CBIC Circular Clarifies Key Taxation Queries on Services and Supplies

CBIC Circular Clarifies Key Taxation Queries on Services and Supplies

The latest directive, GST Circular No. 206/18/2023-GST, dated October 31, 2023, issued by the Tax Research Unit of the Ministry of Finance, India, delves into critical aspects of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and its applicability across various sectors. This circular is pivotal, not only for compliance but also for understanding the nuanced application of GST laws in specific business scenarios. This article examines the circular’s key points, offering an expert interpretation to aid finance professionals in comprehending its broader implications.

Detailed Analysis

1. Leasing of Motor Vehicles Without Operators

The circular clarifies that services like passenger transport (SAC 9964) and renting of motor vehicles with operators (SAC 9966) are categorically different from leasing vehicles without operators (SAC 9973). The critical distinction here is the non-inclusion of leasing under ‘same line of business’, attracting a different GST rate. This decision impacts businesses engaged in vehicle leasing, mandating a reconsideration of their GST computations and input tax credit claims.

Real-world Application:

Consider a company like XYZ Rentals, which primarily rents out cars with drivers but also leases vehicles without operators. While their core services attract a 5% GST with input tax credit, the leasing segment will attract a standard GST rate, necessitating separate accounting treatment.

2. GST on Reimbursement of Electricity Charges

The clarification regarding electricity charges is critical for real estate entities. The directive emphasizes that electricity supply, even when billed separately, is part of a composite supply if bundled with property rentals or maintenance. Thus, it attracts GST corresponding to the principal supply rate.

READ  CBIC Issues New Circular Clarifying GST Place of Supply Rules for Service Sectors

Case Study:

In a scenario where a mall operator charges tenants separately for electricity, this charge is no longer seen as an independent supply but as part of the overall rental composite supply, influencing the GST rate applied.

3. GST Rate for Job Work Processing Barley into Malted Barley

This provision has significant implications for the food and beverage industry, particularly breweries. The classification of malted barley job work under a 5% GST rate, irrespective of its use in alcoholic beverages, offers some relief in an industry grappling with various tax slabs.

Industry Impact:

Breweries like ABC Brewers, outsourcing barley malting, will benefit from lower GST rates on these job works, potentially reducing overall production costs.

4. GST Exemption for District Mineral Foundations Trusts (DMFTs)

The recognition of DMFTs as Governmental Authorities and their exemption from GST aligns with the welfare nature of their operations. This exemption could encourage more robust infrastructure and community development activities in mining-affected areas.


A DMFT in a mining-affected district undertaking projects for water supply or health services can now do so without the added burden of GST, ensuring better fund utilization.

5. GST Exemption on Horticulture Works for CPWD

The circular exempts GST for certain services provided to CPWD, especially in horticulture. This exemption is significant for entities engaged in landscaping and environmental maintenance services, particularly those whose goods value in the composite supply does not exceed 25%.


A landscape service provider like GreenScape working on a government project can now benefit from GST exemption, provided their material cost remains below the stipulated threshold, impacting bidding and pricing strategies.

READ  CBIC Issues Clarification on Export of Services: GST Circular No. 202/14/2023-GST

Conclusions and Forward-Looking Insights

The GST Circular No. 206/18/2023-GST is a commendable effort towards clarifying prevailing ambiguities in the GST regime. Each clarification not only impacts the respective sectors but also guides the interpretation and application of GST law.

Key Takeaways:

  • Businesses must revisit their service classifications and GST computations in light of these clarifications.
  • This circular encourages more transparent, sector-specific guidelines, ensuring ease of doing business.
  • The exemption for DMFTs and specific services to CPWD underlines the government’s focus on infrastructure and environmental projects.

Future Outlook:

  • Ongoing refinement in GST laws will be crucial, especially as new business models and technologies emerge.
  • Vigilant compliance and an adaptive approach towards GST interpretations are vital for businesses.
  • The government may continue to leverage GST policies to stimulate specific sectors, ensuring alignment with broader economic goals.

In conclusion, Circular No. 206/18/2023-GST is not just a regulatory document but a lens through which the evolving landscape of Indian taxation can be viewed and understood, particularly in sectors like transportation, real estate, food and beverage, and public welfare.


Trending Posted

Get Started Live Chat