Latest News SEBI

Why did SEBI Issue a Showcause Notice to Adani Energy?

In a recent development, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) issued a showcause notice to Adani Energy Solutions Ltd, a power transmission business of the Adani Group. The regulatory notice pertains to the alleged wrong categorisation of a certain number of investors as public shareholders.

This notice followed after increased scrutiny by SEBI of the group in recent months, part of a wider investigation into compliance with market regulations, transparency standards, and protection of investor interests.

This blog deals with the notice and its implications, the regulations by SEBI, and how this fits in with a broader probe triggered by allegations of misconduct made earlier by Hindenburg Research.

Understanding SEBI’s Notice: What Happened?

SEBI accused AESL of misclassifying certain investors as public shareholders who actually were promoter-linked investors.

➢   Why It Matters: At least 25% of the equity of a listed company has to be held by public shareholders, according to SEBI. This would ensure sufficient public participation in shareholding and market liquidity.

➢   Promoter Group Link Concerns: The investors who have a close link with the promoter group, like foreign portfolio investors who are directly or indirectly controlled by the promoters themselves, cannot be viewed as public shareholders. Misclassification of these types of investors misguides the market by inflating the figures of public ownership.

AESL, in the second-quarter earnings statement, acknowledged that it had received a notice from SEBI. The company would, in due course, provide the requisite clarifications, information, and documentation to SEBI and other regulatory bodies, it stated. Without divulging the details on the nature of the issue, AESL stated that it would extend full cooperation in the inquiry.

SEBI’s Listing Regulations and Shareholding Structure

The Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements (LODR) of SEBI, is aimed at ushering in transparency without leaving room for market manipulation. According to the provisions under these rules:

• Minimum Public Shareholding: At least 25 per cent of the equity in a listed firm must be held by public shareholders.
• Classification of Promoters and Public Shareholders: Promoter group and related parties/persons form part of promoter holdings. No investor related to the promoter group shall be considered a public shareholder since this would defeat the very principle of adequate public participation.

The alleged misclassification by AESL raises concerns regarding the following:

• Regulatory Violations: It is possible that the promoter-linked entities were incorrectly classified as public shareholders, as the company might be failing to meet the 25% MPS requirement.
• Market Integrity: It may give an appearance of public interest and involvement when, as a matter of fact, it is not. In this, investor sentiment and stock prices are affected.

Adani Group Under Scrutiny – Context of the SEBI Investigation

The exchange notification by Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone follows a broader regulatory investigation initiated by SEBI after the Adani Group faced accusations in January 2023 of corporate malpractice and manipulating stock prices.

Equally disturbing has been a report by Hindenburg Research, a group based in the United States designated as a short-seller, accusing the Adani Group of stock manipulation, improper related-party transactions, and valuations that were inflated. The report took up major controversy upon its release, knocking off roughly $150 billion from the group’s market value at its lowest point.

Group’s Response: The Adani group denied all the charges and termed the report baseless and politically driven. Despite market turmoil, the group started charting the comeback strategy when nearly most of its stocks regained value over time.

Other than the Hindenburg allegations, the investigation of SEBI into the operations of Adani also extended to include:

• Related Party Transactions Compliance: This would determine that intra-group arrangements are suitably disclosed and at arm’s length.

• Foreign Investor Classification: SEBI investigated if foreign portfolio investors related to promoter groups were misclassified with the intent of artificially inflating public shareholding.

• Auditor Compliance Issues: Notices were issued by SEBI challenging the validity of peer review certificates held by their auditors. Connect with experts for effective compliance audit.

SEBI Notices to Other Adani Firms

Adani Enterprises received this notice recently, showing it’s not an isolated incident. In the recent quarters, different group companies of Adani have received show-cause notices from SEBI:

• Adani Enterprises Ltd.
• Adani Green Energy Ltd.
• Adani Total Gas Ltd.
• Adani Power
• Adani Wilmar
• Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone

These notices included various compliance issues ranging from related-party transactions to listing norm violations. Put together, the notices indicate that SEBI is scrutinizing governance practices and market disclosures of the Adani conglomerate more closely.

Implications of SEBI Notice to AESL

This show-cause notice to AESL brings into question some very major issues with respect to corporate governance and investor transparency. If proven, such allegations may attract regulatory action against AESL and reputational damage. Some of the key potential outcomes could be:

• Penalties and Legal Action:

SEBI imposes monetary penalties for non-compliance with market regulations. Apart from that, there is a restatement of the public shareholding structure required for the company, and take corrective measures so as to meet the 25% of the public holding requirement.

• Impact on Share Price and Market Sentiment:

Regulatory notices are often bound to affect investor sentiment, especially in companies already in the line of fire. The stock performance at AESL is likely to turn volatile, especially if the market views this as part of a larger pattern of non-compliances across the Adani group.

• Strengthened Regulatory Scrutiny Across the Group:

With several Adani companies under investigation, regulators could now deploy closer scrutiny of the group’s operations. The other plausible consequence could be that international investors reevaluate their exposure to Adani companies if the issue of governance concerns remains.

Supreme Court’s Involvement and the Expert Committee Report

It was in the wake of the Hindenburg allegations that the issue came up before the Supreme Court of India. While asking SEBI to investigate the allegations, SC constituted an Expert Committee to:

• Look into allegations made against the Adani Group.
• Identify the possible regulatory loopholes.
• Give suggestions on how to reinforce the regulatory regime for listed companies.

Key Findings of the Expert Committee:

The Expert Committee, in its report, said there was no regulatory failure as far as the Adani case is concerned under the existing laws in May 2023. It stressed the need for more vigilance in monitoring foreign investments and transactions involving related parties.

Pending Investigations and SC Directive:

By August 2023, SEBI had completed probing into 22 of the 24 issues relating to the Adani Group. The SC directed SEBI to conclude the remaining two investigations by early 2024.

The Road Ahead for Adani Energy Solutions Ltd

While the show-cause notice is not an indictment, it is a formal query seeking clarification from AESL regarding the alleged misclassification. The company said it would fully cooperate with the regulators and would continue to provide necessary documents and responses. Moving forward, how AESL is able to address the regulator’s concerns quickly and transparently needs to be seen for further damage control of this notice.

Adani’s Recovery Plan:

Adani Group has been working actively, trying to regain market confidence, repair its dented reputation, deleverage, and make better disclosures after the Hindenburg controversy while engaging global investors on its long-term growth potential.

Strengthening Corporate Governance:

Given that regulatory scrutiny does not seem to be over yet, governance practices for the group may need to be enhanced. Also, stricter internal controls will be required to prevent these compliance issues from happening in the future. Transparent reporting and proactive communication with investors will play an important role in retaining shareholder trust.

To Wrap Up

The notice issued by SEBI to Adani Energy Solutions Ltd. is another frontline development in the cavalcade of fights between the Adani Group and the regulator. Allegations of the wrongful categorization of investors bring back the importance of correct disclosure of shareholders for market integrity. While AESL has assured the regulators of full cooperation, the future course of compliance by the company would depend upon the outcome of investigations by SEBI.

As the Adani Group works its way back to stability and recovery, it must be ready to do two things: meet the regulatory challenge and reconstruct market confidence. With multiple Adani companies already in the line of vision of SEBI, the group will have to show unwavering commitment to transparency and good governance if it is to regain investors’ and regulators’ confidence.

If you are looking for expert assistance in replying to notice or SEBI registration services, visit https://enterslice.com/.

FAQ’s